A two-year study into used electrical and electronic equipment (UEEE) sent to Nigeria, mostly from European ports, has revealed a continuing “severe problem” of non-compliance with international and national rules governing such shipments.
Limited functionality testing revealed that, of the UEEE sent to Nigeria every year from other countries in 2015 and 2016 — assessed at around 60,000 metric tonnes in both years— at least 15,400 tonnes didn’t work.
This annual volume of imported e-waste, prohibited under both the Basel Convention and the EU’s Waste Shipment Directive, is enough to fill a 10 kilometre line of full-loaded 36-tonne 18-wheel trucks.
The study also revealed that almost 70% — 41,500 tonnes — of the UEEE reaching Lagos each year arrived inside vehicles destined for Nigeria’s second hand auto market, an import route never before thoroughly assessed. Another 18,300 tonnes arrived in shipping containers.
Co-authored by the Basel Convention Coordinating Centre for Africa (BCCC Africa) and the Sustainable Cycles (SCYCLE) Programme of United Nations University Vice-Rectorate in Europe, the study report says UEEE imported into Nigeria often arrives mixed with other goods such as bicycles, kitchenware, sports equipment, furniture.
More than 60% of the UEEE imported in containers was declared in official paperwork to be household goods or personal effects. UEEE imported in used vehicles was mostly undeclared.
By weight, LCD-TVs and flat panel monitors made up the largest category (18%) of imported UEEE. Over half (55%) of these were found to be non-functioning and as such waste.
The second largest category — CRT-TVs and CRT-monitors (14%) —are formally banned from importation.
Photocopying machines made up 13%, refrigerators 12%, desktop CPUs 7%, air conditioners, speakers and washing machines, each 6%, printers 5%, and DVDs 4%.
Of the UEEE imported inside “roll-on / roll-off” (Ro-Ro) used vehicles (so called because they are driven onto and off the ships rather than being transported in containers) the vast majority (98%) came from EU member states. The rest came from the USA.
Another 18,300 tonnes were imported in containers, predominantly originating from ports in the EU (29%), China (24%) and the USA (20%).
Overall, around 77 % of the assessed UEEE imports originated from ports in the EU, mainly from Germany and the United Kingdom (around 20 % each), followed, with some distance by Belgium, The Netherlands, Spain and Ireland (between 9 % and 6 %). China and the USA each account for around 7 % of the total imports.
The report also notes that some of the devices can and will be repaired in Nigeria. Nevertheless, exporting to and importing non-functional UEEE into Nigeria are illegal under the Basel Convention. Under the Convention, only UEEE that is functional and for reuse may be shipped.
The study also found that none of the illegal shipments resulted in consequences for the exporters or importers.
Due to the conditions in the ports, only basic functionality testing was possible, the report says. Actual volumes of nonfunctional UEEE imports are probably higher than estimated.
The report concludes the first ever, long-term (16 month) study of containers and vehicles in a known destination country for UEEE and WEEE, including a review of import documents. It was conducted in two Nigerian ports in Lagos under the “Person in the Port (PiP)” project implemented by the Basel Convention Coordination Centre for the Africa Region (BCCC-Africa) and the United Nations University (UNU), as part of the Solving the E-waste Problem (Step) Initiative.
The project was co-funded in part by the US Environment Protection Agency (US EPA) and by the German Ministry of Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), via the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit = German International Cooperation (GIZ).
“The importation of UEEE in vehicles is economical for the shippers because it fills valuable space during shipments,” says Prof. Percy Onianwa, Director BCCC Africa. “However, because in particular the contents in RoRo-vehicles’ are not yet on the radar for such tests, this practice serves to avoid inspections and functionality tests on UEEE by the regulatory agency, resulting in many tonnes of e-waste arriving illegally into Nigeria.”
“In the best case scenario, our study shows, at least 15,600 metric tonnes of non-functional UEEE is imported into Nigeria each year. UEEE containing hazardous substances – e.g. mercury and (H)CFCs — are among the products with the highest non-functionality rates and the highest import volumes.”
“Almost all of the importers or their agents are Nigerians, of which 80% are located within the Lagos metropolis,” adds co-author Olusegun Odeyingbo of UNU. “The imports of UEEE can generate considerable profits, especially if they can be sold primarily for re-use.”
“The overall profits depend on the quality and the brand of the UEEE, and on the exchange rate of the Nigerian currency, the Naira, in particular with the US dollar and the Euro.”
“The main business potential of UEEE is re-use, as this enables highest sales value,” he notes. “Imports of e-waste return only marginal profits based on material value alone making it more attractive to import functional or repairable UEEE. Where UEEE is broken, repair and spare parts harvesting offer higher value returns before recycling for material value.”
According to the report: “The enforcement of regulations in the countries of export, mainly in the EU and in Nigeria, need to be strengthened, and closer cooperation amongst local regulatory and enforcement agencies is highly advisable.”
Says Ruediger Kuehr, Director of UNU’s SCYCLE Programme in charge of e-waste: “Next steps should involve making certificates of functionality testing an obligatory part of the requirements for transporting used electronic and electrical equipment, along with standard functionality tests, accepted by both exporting and importing countries, for each type of UEEE. Furthermore, projects of this type are needed in other parts of the world to better understand the magnitude and dynamics of these imports and exports.”
* * * * *
Used Electronic and Electrical Equipment (UEEE) received in Nigeria in 2015 and 2016
By the numbers:
2,184: roll-on/roll-off (Ro-Ro) used vehicles inspected, of which 1,195 (55 %) were loaded with used lectrical and electronic equipment
201: shipping containers inspected
3,622: inspected import documents for UEEE in containers
Of the 60,000 tonnes: total weight of observed UEEE shipped to Nigeria in both 2015 and 2016, about 41,500 tonnes per year arrived in RoRo used vehicles, over 18,300 tonnes per year arrived in containers (considered a minimum due to suspected under-declaration of the weight of imported goods and missing import documents)
About 77%: UEEE arriving in Nigeria from ports in the European Union
About 85%: UEEE arriving in Nigeria from ports in just eight countries, including roughly:20%: Germany; 19.5%: UK; 9.4%: Belgium; 8.2%: The Netherlands; 7.4%: Spain; 7.3%: China; 7.3%: USA; 6.2%: Ireland
Of the ~41,500 tonnes of UEEE arriving in Nigeria each year in RoRo vehicles, 98% was shipped from ports in the European Union: 28%: Germany; 24%: UK; 13%: Belgium; 12%: The Netherlands; 9%: Ireland; 5%: Spain; 7%: other EU. (2% originated from US ports)
Of the 18,300+ tonnes of UEEE per year shipped in containers, roughly 29% originated from ports in EU member states; 24% originated from China; 20% from USA
Of the 260 tonnes of CRT-devices shipped to Nigeria in 2015 and 2016, despite being banned by the Nigerian Government, roughly 23% arrived from ports in China; 15% from USA; 14% from UK; 14% from Spain; 8% from Italy; 4% from Hong Kong; 4% from Netherlands; 20% from other countries.
* * * * *
Basel Convention Coordinating Centre for the African Region (BCCC-Africa) (www.basel.org.ng)
BCCC-Africa is one of the fourteen regional centres established globally under the provisions of the Basel Convention to support parties to the convention in meeting their obligations to implement the Convention. The centres are mandated to conduct capacity building trainings, information dissemination, technology transfer and research. BCCC-Africa has been very actively involved in studying the e-waste problem in parts of Africa.
United Nations University (www.unu.edu)
UNU is an autonomous organ of the UN General Assembly dedicated to generating and transferring knowledge and strengthening capacities relevant to global issues of human security, development, and welfare. The University operates through a worldwide network of research and training centres and programmes, coordinated by UNU Centre in Tokyo.
The Bonn, Germany-based Sustainable Cycles (SCYCLE) Programme hosted by UNU’s Vice Rectorate in Europe is providing world-class research and action on e-waste. SCYCLE aims to enable societies to reduce the environmental burden caused by the production, consumption and disposal of ubiquitous goods.
Solving the E-waste Problem (Step) Initiative (www.step-initiative.org)
The Solving the E-waste Problem (Step) Initiative emerged in 2004 as an independent multi-stakeholder platform for designing strategies that address all dimensions of electronics in an increasingly digitized world. The Step mission is to apply an integrated, science-rooted approach to create salient solutions to global e-waste challenges along the entire electronic life cycle.